BMAT Section 3 is a handwritten task with a choice of three essays and 30 minutes to write one A4 page. So how should you approach this section to maximise your score?
NOTE: BMAT will take place on 18 October 2023 and will be a pen-and-paper test.
BMAT will be withdrawn from 2024. Keep an eye on our TikTok channel and live updates article to find out what's happening with BMAT universities after next year.
This is more challenging for some than others. Read our BMAT FAQ to find out more about the test, but your end goal is to find which sections are most challenging for you. Do this as early as possible to help plan your preparation.
Our BMAT specification article takes you through what you need to know for each section. If you get a lot of 'that's obvious' for a certain section, prioritise one of the others.
Explanation of the proposition
You could be asked to explain a proposition in the task or to explain a certain part of it. You may also be asked to explain the implications of the proposition.
Generation of a counterargument
This one is about seeing things from an alternative point of view and either proposing a counterargument or commenting on one.
Reconciliation of two sides
This involves suggesting a solution that addresses both the proposition and the counter-proposition, i.e. building bridges between ideas.
Giving your opinion
It’s likely that you'll be asked ‘To what extent…’ – this question is asking you to give your judgement.
The purpose of this section is to assess your ability to examine different sides of an argument and communicate clearly and concisely. This is a vital part of being a doctor.
The writing tasks generally relate to the following areas:
You’ll get a score from 1 to 5 (with 5 being the highest) for the quality of content and a band between A to E (with A being the highest) for quality of English.
To find out more about scoring and what candidates typically get, read our article: What is a good BMAT score?
We recommend you spend at least a minute or two actively deciding which question to do, especially as Section 3 is not very time pressured.
Choose your question wisely. Actively go through each of the essay titles thinking about what points you have to address. Pick the one you have the most thoughts on.
Avoid ploughing in, only to realise you have two weak points!
Plan your essay carefully by spending up to ten minutes on it. Plan to the point where you know exactly what you are going to write.
Split the plan into two parts:
This is the brain dump phase. Write down everything you know about the subject.
This is the organisation phase. Organise the dumped material into a coherent and logical structure.
If your prompt is ‘obese people shouldn't be treated under the NHS because it's a self-inflicted condition’, the subsections might be:
In the brain dump phase, write as many points as you possibly can and add any examples or facts. For the organisation phase, pick one or two strong points from each section, then work out how they are going to flow together.
If you have time left over, it's useful to proofread what you have written to make sure it all makes sense and is readable. Of course, you must also check that you have answered all parts of the question.
Thinking of this section as an essay can make a lot of people worry. If you spend around 15 minutes choosing your question and planning, this leaves you with around 15 minutes to write your ‘essay’. In most circumstances, you don’t write an essay in 15 minutes and you usually write well over a page for an essay.
Thinking of this as an essay means that you’re more likely to try to write elaborate and long winded sentences and fit in as many topics as possible. This section is about getting to the point quickly and elegantly.
Think of BMAT Section 3 as an 8 or 9 mark piece of writing in GCSE English. It’s not an essay, it’s a short writing task. This will help you get a better understanding of the amount of content you need to cover.
This is really important. Read the question and re-read it. You might even want to make a small checklist at the side. If you don’t address everything that you’re being asked, your score will be capped at a 2 no matter how good your work is.
'That which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.' - Christopher Hitchens
Explain what you think Christopher Hitchens means. Argue to the contrary that some assertions do not require evidence. To what extent do you agree with the statement?
It’s easy to overlook the final question when pushed for time. Make yourself a checklist like the one below and assign time for each section.
It’s important to write as neatly as possible. Scruffy handwriting makes life harder for examiners. This can obscure any excellent points that you make.
Making your writing small, while still keeping it legible, means you can fit more work in the space provided.
That means short and sweet. You only have one page, so cut out any unnecessary commentary and irrelevant sentences.
After you’ve written your answer under timed conditions, re-read it and trim the fat. Try to spot any areas where you’re waffling or repeating yourself and highlight them. This will make your writing crisp and succinct.
Here are some ways you can make your writing more concise:
There are multiple ways of saying the same thing. Choose the shortest. Avoid phrases like 'first and foremost' or 'each and every'. Using multiple synonyms can also make your writing clunky.
Remove unnecessary qualifiers
Qualifiers such as 'basically', 'probably', 'definitely', 'somewhat', 'slightly' aren’t always necessary.
Passive writing, such as 'The ball was thrown by James', is usually wordier than active writing ('James threw the ball').
Use words instead of phrases
Use words that mean the same thing instead of phrases. For example, instead of 'due to the fact that', use 'because' or 'since'.
'Each and every individual in the medical and wider healthcare team plays an absolutely crucial and vital role in the delivery of high-quality care that ensures the wellbeing and overall safety of the patient that they’re associated with.' can be rewritten more concisely as 'The multidisciplinary team plays a crucial role in delivering quality care to ensure patient safety.'
Cutting out repetition of synonyms like 'crucial' and 'vital' and qualifiers like 'absolutely' allows you to convey the same meaning more elegantly.
It’s likely that your question will be based on ethics or philosophy so read up on those topics.
Familiarise yourself with different types of ethics, such as:
Another strategy is to read books on philosophy or philosophical quotes and then try to think of counterarguments. The more you read, the more you can draw upon in your essay.
No time for reading? Watch YouTube videos about philosophy or ethics. The School of Life has a great playlist that discusses various philosophers and their views. Wireless Philosophy has a really detailed playlist on ethics.
Ever heard of playing devil’s advocate?
Debating will help you create counterarguments. Debate with friends, family or teachers. Once you’ve got the hang of creating counterarguments, it’ll become second nature for you during the exam.
Support your points with examples or statistics. Since there’s such a wide range of topics for BMAT Section 3, it’s unrealistic to learn statistics for every single thing. This is why it’s important to be well read. The more you read, the more likely you are to be able to use something you’ve seen.
If you don’t have any statistics to quote, don’t be tempted to make things up. BMAT examiners may look up the things you quote, so don’t say anything that would make examiners question your credibility.
After writing your essay, get feedback from everyone you can think of. This will help achieve objectivity.
Use this checklist to assess your writing
It’s important to be aware of what’s going on in the medical world and in the wider scientific world. This will help you to draw upon real life examples in the exam.
Sources to check out: